UNIT 1. KNOWLEDGE
1. BASIC CONCEPTS: Thoughts, beliefs, opinions and knowledge.
a) 'to wonder': -To ask oneself about something that surprises us, which causes amazement ('wonderful': 'full of wonder') or uncertainty ('I wonder why she did that').
-Making oneself questions about something that causes us curiosity ('Quest': a search, to look for something as a personal challenge -in this case: an answer)
(In Spanish: 'preguntarse algo' cuando algo nos causa asombro o curiosidad, buscando explicación)
b) 'to think': act or process from our mind by which it tries to answer a question, to solve any doubt or problem
(In Spanish: 1. 'estar meditando o reflexionando sobre algo sobre lo que aún no se ha decidido nada o no se tiene aún una posición'
-'She's thinking about quitting her job' (to be thinking about sth.)
2. 'expresar opinión o posición personal sobre algo, pero que no constituye una creencia irrenunciable: 'opinar que', 'creer que' -'He thinks that people wouldn't fancy living in another planet' ('to think that....')
3. 'tener en mente o venirnos a la mente algo o alguien'
-'I think of you constantly'(to think of sth or sb)
'thoughts': the outcome of the process of thinking about an issue, or the particular problem something is minding without expressing it ('Reflections' is not so commonly used, and it is still attached to the etimological metaphor of 'the conscience as a mirror' where thoughts and memories are like 'images' there reflected')
-'His thoughts yesterday about the meaning of life were a bit creepy'.
-'One penny for your thoughts'
-'Freedom of thought and freedom of press are ones of the basic liberties iWestern Culture'
'a thinker': someone whose thoughts are considered as innovative or interesting, worth the while to pay attention to, because they open new perspectives or points of view about questions.
(In Spanish: 'alguien del que se reconoce la valía de sus reflexiones, no porque aporte conocimiento, sino porque 'nos dan qué pensar', motivan a la meditación o reflexión'.)
c) 'to believe': to trust that something is true; it can mean (a) a strong bet on an option, when there's an awareness that it could be a mistake, but it usually (b) comes with a personal attachment, as a personal principle, a moral value or faith that a person doesn't doubt at all (somebody's personal beliefs).
(a)
-'I believe them right now, though yesterday they lied to me.'
-'I don't believe that's true' (stronger than 'I don't think that's true')
(b)
-'I believe in you'
-'I believe that what goes around comes around'.
-'They believe in the afterworld'
-'She only believes in power and money. Do you believe that there's something else worth the effort than the material things?
'belief': strong personal feeling that something is true, usually somebody's moral principles or personal values.
-'Freedom of belief and public tolerance towards different cults and faith is the foundation of the modern world'
'a believer': a person who follows a particular faith, usually sharing it in cults and rituals in a community with others with the same beliefs.
'a wise person': a person who is reckoned as having practical principles or values that make him have a good life and keep good social relation with others, and whose opinion and advise is taken on account by others.
'wisdom': the right attitudes, ways of behaviour and care about one's own business that brings welfare (practical knowledge).
d) 'to know': to have learned that something is true for sure, without any doubt or need to believe in it, that can be taught and proved to anyone. (It can be learned from one's own experience, from others, from theories socially admitted as true). 'to can' is used when it means 'to know how to do sth in general' ('He doesn't know how to dance at all' = 'He can't dance'; 'He can really cook!' = 'He really knows how to cook quite well')
'-I'm completely shocked! Mariah is going out with her ex. -Yeah, I know.
'-Who knows the anwer about the meaning of life?'
'-I know you. You didn't do it. You aren't able to do such a thing'.
'-He doesn't really know how to mend that.'= 'He can't really mend that'
'knowledge': The whole information, data or theories accepted as true in a society that a person can learn. ('Only in the long run you'll be able to get the whole knowledge in that field.') Or the whole information, data and different explanations that a person has learned about something ('Her knowledge about plants is amazing', 'That's something I have little knowledge about.')
'research': Methodical investigation, trying to prove some hypothesis or conjectures with strict rules to test the possible outcomes, in order to solve a problem in any field: 'medical research' in order to get a cure for cancer; 'genetic research' in order to decodify one person's disposition to illness, 'technological research' in order to improve the 'rendimiento' extracted from energy resources,...
-----------------------------------------
Exercise 1.: Which of these statements express (1) thoughts, (2) opinions, (3) beliefs or (4) knowledge? (It doesn't matter if they are true or false, or whether the concepts aren't used as we defined above)
a.-'I already know that water is composed by hydrogen and oxygen'
b.-'Better alone than in bad company.'
c.-'Don't ask me why, but I know for sure that she will come.'
d.-'It seems that what goes around comes around, sooner or later'
e.-'Don't you get so upset, please. I only said that I didn't think she would come in time'
f.-'You got your hand burnt because the bowl's handler was made of metal and metals are good heat conductors.'
g.-'Genius without education is like silver in the mine'.
h.-'I've got the feeling that this will be a good year.'
i.-'One man can have all the knowledge of the universe, and still won't get wise enough to get the common happiness of a housewife or a clerk'
j.-'If an apple falls to the floor is so because it is attracted by the Earth.'
k.-'Sharing good times with friends multiplies happiness, and good friends minorize sorrow as you can lean on them.'
l.-'Dolphins and whales are fish because they live in the sea'.
m.-'Without our constitutional freedoms, modern life wouldn't make sense.'
n.'The root of 16 is 4 because a number's root is its half.'
ñ.-'Love your enemies, for they will tell you your faults.'
o.-'I think, without any doubt, that there are intelligent living beings in the outter space'
p.-'If money could buy anything, a millionaire couldn't be unhappy'.
2. TWO KINDS OF EXPLANATION:
LOGICAL or DEDUCTIVE THINKING
& NARRATIVE or METAPHORICAL THINKING
Reason and articulated language is one of the specific differences between human beings and the rest of the species. Thinking is what defines us traditionally as humans.
The other one is freedom from natural instincts and the will to decide accomplishing a target on the long run, putting apart the inmediate satisfaction desires and impulses against that target, and choosing the ones that helps us fulfill our ends. Voluntary and responsible action (choosing between 'good' or 'bad') is also essentially human.
In the first stages of their lives, other evolved species can also show curiosity and play with things that surprises them as 'new' -but not dangerous at all- (kitties, puppets, dolphins,...). But we are born instinctually quite disconected from a particular environment (which allows us to live in any environment). So, humans can feel amazed anytime about any phaenomena, and look at it as if it were the first time they see it, all brand new, surprising us of just 'being' or 'exist' like that.
From the beggining of time, some humans started to wonder why the world surrounding us existed and was like that. To wonder about something means feeling suprised or amazed and the desire to know how that can be. At the origin, the whole world was 'full of wonder' and led us to asking questions and looking for answers. A cat or a dog runs to cover so as to feel safe from the noise of thunder. Besides that, humans wondered why that happened in that way in that moment. Humans are the only species that ask themselves questions and look for satisfying answers. Here begins the search for knowledge.
Aristotle -s. IV B.C. in Ancient Greece-, said that thought was born when humans had their needs satisfied and could had leasure time to stop to wonder about every aspect of the world they saw around: beauty, darkness, light, pleasure, harm... Making questions starts a quest, looking for an explanation. In this sense, every human is a philosoph, and likes to know.
There are two ways of giving an explanation. The first one was the 'narrative explanation'. 'Narrative explanations' are not only ancient myths, but any try to bring human sense to an unknown and distant phaenomena (or too close, as passions), expressing it through metaphors and symbolic language that brings out comparisons with other emotional and closer experiences. To express the unknown through the already known and familiar, so as to know how to cope with it, making it 'part of our world'.
The second one was the 'logical or deductive explanation'. Strictly 'rational explanations' tend not to use symbolic language or metaphors, but only denotative terms which anybody can test in their common experience, so as to control the phenomena, creating technics and make the world more comfortable.
Historically, Western Culture rose through its tecnological civilization as an outcome from scientific research, based on the 'rational explanations' that were first originated in Ancient Greece. With the scientificism or positivism in the XIX century and the expression 'from mythos to logos', 'narrative explanations' were put aside and considered even useless and an obstacle for 'rational thinking'. Nevertheless, it conceals that most of mankind still uses 'narrative explanations' to bring sense and guide them through their lives, and that even in learning or research, we still use 'narrative explanations' with metaphors, symbols or comparisons, trying to bring light to certain complex phaenomena and general truths.
(A)-'Narrative explanations' bring 'understanding' or 'comprehension'. Are used constantly in research, knowledge and apprenticeship as an 'heuristic' or creative way to approach something difficult to understand.
(B)-'Deductive explanations' bring 'strict 'mechanical' explanations'. Are used as the official way to prove the inner necessity of something ('appodictic'):
|
|
'NARRATIVE' EXPLANATION
(though it has its own 'logic')
|
'DEDUCTIVE' EXPLANATION
(though something can be strictly rational but not reasonable at all)
|
|
LANGUAGE
|
SIMBOLS AND METAPHORS WITH MULTIPLE MEANINGS
-Use of metaphors, symbols and analogies. (Poetical language)
-They allow to express aspects from the unknown as resemblances of aspects from familiar experiences.
|
DENOTATIVE TERMS WITH ONLY ONE MEANING
-Use of strict denotative language. (Dictionary language)
-The empirical concepts allow us to express descriptions that could be tested thru empirical experience by anyone.
|
|
CONSTRUCTION
|
ANTROPOMORPHISM & SPIRITUALISM
-Project human or 'spiritual' cualities in the principles or first causes of the phenomena or facts we're trying to explain.
-It allows us to understand them, and making posible to bound us emotionally in a familiar way, so as to adopt 'rituals' or habits to get on with them. (Mending the broken vow with the universe, re-ligatio)
|
NATURALISM & MATERIALISM
-Project strictly 'natural' or 'material' properties in the principles or first causes of the phenomena of facts we're trying to explain.
-The theoric concepts must have the same natural qualities that we may find in the phaenomena or facts as their effects. (Cause-Effect relation must be homogenic (of the same nature) and proportional)
-This explanations, as they try to predict the phenomena behaviour, are supposed to give a way to manipulate technically the phenomena in human benefit thru technology.
|
|
STRUCTURE
|
TRASCENDENT OR SUPERNATURAL
-The first cause exist in a different order of things, and doesn't follow the same rules as the natural phenomena it explains -it exceeds or trascends the natural order-. -As it exists in 'another' world, from which it causes the natural world we percieve, it's called 'supernatural' explanation.
|
INMANENT OR MATERIAL
-The first cause exist inside the same order of things, and follows the same rules as the phenomena it explains. That's why it's called 'natural' explanation.
-As it reduces the causes to the same kind of material cualities of effects we percieve thru our senses, it's called inmanent cause and 'material explanation'
|
|
MOMENT IN TIME
|
'EXTRA-ORDINARY' MOMENTS OR 'INDETERMINED MOMENT' OR 'OUT OF TIME'
-The moment of producing the phenomena or fact was at the beggining of time, or in an not-determined moment in the past 'Once upon a time', or in an extrarodinary moment (as a miracle).
-Since then, the unlimited power from the first cause maintains the effect happening as we experience.
|
ORDINARY SITUATIONS AND CONTINUOUSLY CAUSING THE PHENOMENA
-The principles or causes are acting non-stop inside the phaenomena.
-The natural power of the mechanism is explicited by our measures and theory and we can inhibite it or manipulate it, producing technics.
|
|
DISCIPLINES
|
- LITERATURE, ARTS, RELIGION, MORAL GUIDANCE, PHILOSOPHY (Plato & Nietzsche, for instance).
-Though in Literature and Moral guidance, the deductive thinking is used to predict consequences and create expectations to the reader or listener. And in religion, Theology uses reason and deduction to introduce to the complex mysteries, and rational arguments to defend the rationality of the faith. And in arts, there are a lot of research and deductive explanations about the process of creation and performance.
|
- SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY, PHILOSOPHY (Aristotle & Kant, for instance)
-Though in Science, the inspiration for hypothesis and conjectures can be brought up by metaphors, beliefs, analoguies, etc. The creative inspiration for new scientific theories or engineering inventions comes out from any field thanks to the imagination. For example, the concept of 'Absolute time' in Newton comes from his religious faith, and 'natural selection' in the 'Theory of evolution' is a metaphor brought up by the comparison with the 'artificial selection' that humans have done to have the farming plants and domestic animals 'evolved'.
|
Exercise 2. Narrative explanation:
-In his first writing about freedom of press, Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790) ended it with this tale of a donkey and a father and his son.
1.-Which discipline of knowledge does this tale belong to? (Philosophy, Religion, Literature, Arts or Moral guidance)
2.-Which is Franklin's position about the lesson learnt thru this tale?
"Franklin ended his "Apology for Printers" with a fable about a father and son traveling with a donkey. When the father rode and made his son walk, they were criticized by those they met; likewise, they were criticized when the son rode and made the father walk, or when they both rode the donkey, or when neither did. So finally, they decided to throw the donkey off a bridge. The moral, according to Franklin, was that it is foolish to try to avoid all criticism. Despite this "despair of pleasing everybody", Franklin concluded, "I shall not burn my press or melt my letters." (ISAACSON: Benjamin Franklin. An American life.)
3. HUMAN KNOWLEDGE: Philosophy, Science, Religion, Arts, Technics, and Morals.
Science is not the only way nor field where humans experience knowledge. Philosophy, religion, arts, technics and morals bring different kinds of knowledge in their own ways:
A) PHILOSOPHICAL THINKING: Systematical reflections which (a) introduces us to all the possible different points of view (theories or opinions) about an issue and their problems, (b) try to make clearer the meaning of the conceptions and terms we use or (c) search for the roots and basic elements of its foundation. Usually, it offers and legitimate (d) a new perspective, a new approach to the problem or even solution (as classical Western thinkers).
Philosophical reflections can begin from the most particular and singular experiences than anyone can have. But their conclusions can be highly speculative and abstract, though always expresses every reasons to accept every step of thinking. And can also use simbolic and metaphors in 'narrative explanations' so as to make clearer a point.
B) SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH: Methodical investigation with strict rules at every step of its process so as to discover the inner natural mechanism by witch a phaenomenon is produced. Begins with the empirical rigorous description and measure of dimensions and relations of all the phenomena related (which includes only denotative terms and language so as to contrast their real reference in our experience). Follows with an inspirational and creative hypotesis or conjecture from which deduce a theoric explanation. And it ends proving its truth when, in an experiment is able to predict the behaviour of new or unexplained complex phenomena. As an outcome, it can develope new technics and tecnology thanks to the manipulation of the inner mechanism in nature that has discovered.
Science is related to philosophy because it needs to argue and question other tehories, and even the misuse of their own terms. It's also related with art and technology because scientists need inspiration and be creative with new procedures and technics to prove their ideas. And can also bring inspiration from personal beliefs, experiences or even literature and mystical conceptions (religions).
C) RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE (FAITH): Feeling of bonding with the ultimate principle of being, which brings sense to existence. It usually comes with its Revelation, expressed in a sacred book for a whole community, which contains the acceptable system of beliefs and rituals, given as the truth and goodness of human life.
Though it is usually expressed in 'narrative explanations', profetic language with symbolic and metaphorical terms, when believers try to (a) make clear some aspects of the Revelation or (b) justify the rationality of their faith before non-believers, use universal reasons and strictly rational argumentation, founding Theology. Religion has in common with philosophy the aspiration to answer the last questions about human existence. Religion also uses art in order to express symbolically or reflect aesthetically their beliefs. And though their relation changed with the positivism in the XIX century, faith has also motivated scientific research, so as to look for hints about the existence of God (and the discovering of laws of nature was a traditional argument in favor of the existence of God).
D) ARTISTIC CREATION or PERFORMANCE: Expressing emotions, perceptions, thoughts or representing an aspect of the world through different materials, with the target of transmiting an aesthetic experience in the senses of the audience. It can express beauty, the sublime and cause pleasure and wonder, or even motivate to reflection. Through language: poetry and literature; through sound: music; through movement: dance; through play: theatre and cinema; through images: picture and photography; through materia: sculpture, and so on.
Though it usually uses intuition and inspiration and it doesn't come by logic rules, but by the imagination, artists need sometimes to clarify their process and their works, so they need to use philosophical thinking. In order to create their works of art, they need to know how to manage different materials, and learn technics and procedures.
E) TECHNICAL or ENGINEERING PROCEDURES: Ability to create tools, instruments, machines, energy resources or media (and the rules or instruccions for their use), so as to manipulate our environment and make the work to satisfy our desires and needs easier.
It uses the discoverings made in science research about the inner mechanism of phaenomena, in order to use it for human benefit. But the tools or machines can come to mind through the inspirations of the imagination, and maybe artistic creation.
F) MORAL GUIDANCE: Principles and values that each person assumes as guidance to his actions, believing is the right thing to do (or at least for his own good).
It has in common with religion that personal values are also principles as beliefs. And the believers bring out of their religion their moral guidance. Moral values can be expressed in logical terms, but also with narrative explanations.
4. THE METHOD OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH:
0) WONDERING ABOUT THE REASON WHY A PHAENOMENON HAPPENS.
A) EMPIRICAL OBSERVATION of the phaenomena: (DATA or EVIDENCE).
-CLEAR AND NEAT COMMON INTUITION THRU ANYONE'S SENSES
-Describing the facts with stricts terms and the right expression
-Measuring their dimensions and moments of their appearances
-Stipulating relations with another facts with which they have concurrence (what happens before -possible causes or factors-, what happens after -possible effects or outcomes).
B) STIPULATE GENERALIZATIONS (EMPIRICAL LAWS).
-INDUCTION FROM PARTICULAR CASES TO GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS.
-For example: 'Any time 'x' happens, 'y' follows' (but we don't know why or how).
C) CREATE AN HYPOTHESIS OR CONJECTURE (THEORY)
-INSPIRATION FROM ANY OTHER FIELD OF EXPERIENCE (ANALOGIES)
-Suppose that the phaenomena is caused or produced by some elements we can't perceive, from which its behaviour and appearences can be explained.
D) GIVE AN EXPLANATION (DEDUCTIVE REASONING):
-DEDUCTION FROM THE HYPOTHESIS, AS LOGICAL CONSEQUENCES, THE BEHAVIOUR OF THE PHAENOMENON
E) TRY TO PROVE THE EXPECTATIONS FROM OUR THEORY: EXPERIMENTS. (VERIFYING OR FALSIFYING ITS IMPLICATIONS (REFUTING IT OR MAKING A REBUTTAL), AND CORRECTING IT (REINFORCING), UNTIL PREDICTING NEW FACTS OR COMPLEX PHAENOMENA)
F) TECHNOLOGICAL APPLIANCES, MAKING HUMAN LIFE MORE COMFORTABLE.
Exercise 4. Scientific research:
-Read this scerpt from Benjamin Franklin's biography, and identify the previous phases of the scientific research 0) a) b) c) d) e) f) :
"In the journal he kept for his experiments, Franklin noted in November 1749 some intriguing similarities between electrical sparks and lightning. He listed twelve of them, including: "1. Giving light. 2. Color of the light. 3. Crooked directions. 4. Swift motion. 5. Being conducted by metals. 6. Crack or noise in exploding... 9. Destroying animals... 12. Sulpherous smell."
More important, he made a connection between this surmise about lightning and his earlier experiments on the power of pointed metal objects to draw off electrical charges. "Electrical fluid is attracted by points. We do not know whether this property is in lightning. But since they agree in all particulars wherein we can already compare them, is it not probable they agree likewise in this?" To which he added a momentous rallying cry: "Let the experiment be made."
For centuries, the devastating scourge of lightning had generally been considered a supernatural phenomenon or expression of God's will. At the approach of a storm, church bells were rung to ward off the bolts. (...) But even the most religiously faithful were likely to have noticed this was not very effective. During one thirty-five-year period in Germany alone during the mid-1700s, 386 churches were struck and more than one hundred bell ringers killed. In Venice, some three thousand people were killed when tons of gunkpowder stored in a church was hit. As Franklin later recalled to Harvard professor John Winthrop, "The lighning seems to strike steeples of choice and at the very time the bells are ringing; yet still they continuo to bless the new bells and jangle the old ones whenever it thunders. One would think it was now time to try some other trick."
Many scientists, including Newton, had noted the apparent connection between lightning and electricity. But no one had declared "Let the experiment be made," nor laid out a methodical test, nor thought of the practicality of tying this all in with the power of pointed metal rods.
Franklin first sketched out his theories about lightning in April 1749, just before his end-of-season turkey fry. The water vapors in a cloud can be electrically charged, he surmised, and the positive ones will separate from the negative ones. When such "electrified clouds pass over," he added, "high trees, lofty towers, spires, masts of ships... draw the electrical fire and the whole cloud discharges." It was not a bad guess, and it led to some practical advice: "Dangerous therefore it is to take shelter under a tree during a thunder gust." It also led to the most famous of all his experiments.
Before he tried to conduct his proposed experiments himself, Franklin described them in two famous letters to Collinson in 1750, which were presented to the Royal Society in London and then widely published. The essential idea was to use a tall metal rod to draw some of the electrical charge from a cloud, just as he had used a needle to draw off the charge of an iron ball in his lab. He detailed his proposed experiment:
On the top of some high tower or steeple, place a kind of sentry box big enough to contain a man and an electrical stand. From the middle of the stand, let an iron rise... upright 20 or 30 feet, pointed very sharp at the end. If the electgrical stand be kept clean and dry, a man standing on it when such clouds are passing low might be electrified and afford sparks, the rod drawing fire to him from the cloud. If any danger to the man be apprehended (though I think there would be none) let him stand on the floor of his bosx, and now and then bring near to the rod the loop of a wire that has one end fastened to the leads; he holding it by a wax handle [i.e., insulating him from it]. So the sparks, if the rod is electrified, will strike from the rod to the wire and not affect him.
Franklin's one mistake was thinking that there would be no danger, as at least one European experimenter fatally discovered. His suggestion of using a wire held with an insulating wax handle was a smarter approach.
If his suppositions held true, Franklin wrote in another letter to Collinson, then lightning rods could tame one of the greatest natural dangers people faced. "Houses, ships and even towns and churches may be effectually secured from the stroke of lightning by their means," he predicted. "The electrical fire would, I think, be drawn out of a cloud silently." He wasn't certain, however. "This may seem whimsical, but let it pass for the present until I send the experiments at large."
Franklin's letters were excerpted in London by The Gentleman's Magazine in 1750 and then published as an eighty-six-page booklet the follosing year. More significant, they were translated into French in early 1752 and became a sensation. King Louis XV asked that the lab tests be performed for him, which they were in February by three Frenchmen who had translated Franklin's experiments, led by the naturalists Comte de Buffon and Thomas-François D'Alibard. The king was so excited that the encouraged the group to try Franklin's proposed lightning rod experiment. As a letter to London's Royal Society noted, "These applauses of his Majesty having excited in Messieurs de Buffon, D'Alibard and de Lor adesire of verifying the conjectures of Mr. Franklin upon the analogy of thunder and electricity, they prepared themselves for making the experiment."
In the village of Marly, on the northern outskirts of Paris, the Frenchmen constructed a sentry box with a 40-foot iron rod and dragooned a retired soldier to play Prometheus. On May 10, 1752, just after 2 in the afternoon, a storm cloud passed over and the soldier was able to draw sparks as Franklin had predicted. An excited local prior grabbed the insulated wire and repeated the experiment six times, shocking himself once but surviving to celebrate the success. Within weeks it was replicated dozens of times across France. "M. Franklin's idea has ceased to be a conjecture," D'Alibard reported to the Franch Royal Academy. "Here it has become a reality."
Though he did not yet know it, Franklin had become an international sensation. An ecstatic Collinson wrote from London that "the Grand Monarch of France strictly commands" that his scientists convey "compliments in an express manner to Mr. Franklin of Philadelphia, for the useful discoveries in electricity and application of the pointed rods to prevent the terrible effects of thunderstorms."
The following month, before word of the French success reached America, Franklin came up with his own ingenious way to conduct the experiment, according to accounts later written by himself and his friend the scientist Joseph Priestley. He had been waiting for the steeple of Philadelphia's Christ Church to be finished, so he could use its high vantage point. Impatient, he struck on the idea of using instead a kite, a toy he had enjoyed flying and experimentiung with since his boyhood days in Boston. To do the experiment in some secrecy, he enlisted his son, William, to help fly the silk kite. A sharp wire protruded from its top and a key was attached near the base of the wet string, so that a wire could be brought near it in an effort to draw sparks.
Clouds passed over to no effect. Franklin began to despair when he suddenly saw some of the strands of the string stiffen. Putting his knuckle to the key, he was able to draw sparks (and, notably, to survive). He proceeded to collect some of the charge in a Leyden jar and found it had the same qualities as electricity produced in a lab. "Thereby the sameness of electrical matter with that of lightning," he reported in a letter the following October, was "completely demonstrated." (...)
Whatever his reason for delaying the report of his experiment, Franklin was prompted that summer to convince the citizens of Philadelphia to erect at least two grounded lightning rods on high buildings, which were apparently the first in the world to be used for protection. That September, he also erected a rod on his own house with an ingenious device to warn of the approaching of a storm. (...)
Nor should we underestimate the practical significance of proving that lightning, once a deadly mystery, was a form of electricity that could be tamed. Few scientific discoveries have been of such immediate service to humanity. The great German philosopher Inmanuel Kant called him the "new Prometheus" for stealing the fire of heaven. He quickly became not only the most celebrated scientist in America and Europe, but also a popular hero. In solving one of the universe's greatest mysteries, he had conquered one of nature's most terrifying dangers." (ISAACSON: Benjamin Franklin. An American life.)
5. DIFFERENT OPINIONS: A POLITE RATIONAL DISCUSSION.
Exercise:
-Write down the advices Franklin gives us so as to discuss in a polite way not to get on other people's nerves.
-Try also to explain the reasons he gives.
"Franklin was worried that his fondness for conversation and eagerness to impress made him prone to "prattling, punning and joking, which only made me acceptable to trifling company." Knowledge, he realized, "was obtained rather by the use of the ear than of the tongue." So in the Junto, he began to work on his use of silence and gentle dialogue.
One method, which he had developed during his mock debates with John Collins in Boston and then when discoursing with Keimer, was to prusue topics through soft, Socratic queries. That became the preferred style for Jun to meetings. Discussions were to be conducted "without fondness for dispute or desire of victory". Franklin taught his friends to push their ideas through suggestions and questions, and to use (or at least feign) naïve curiosity to avoid contradicting people in a manner that could give offense. "All expressions of positiveness in opinion or of direct contradiction," he recalled, "were prohibited under small pecuniary penalties." It was a style he would urge on the Constitutional Convention sixty years later.
In a witty newspaper piece called "On Conversation", which he wrote shortly after forming the Junto, Franklin stressed the importance of deferring, or at least giving the appearance of deferring, to others. Otherwise, even the smartest comments would "occasion envy and disgust". His secret for how to win friends and influence people read like an early Dale Carnegie course: "Would you win the hearts of others, you must not seem to vie with them, but to admire them. Give them every opportunity of displaying their own qualifications, and when you have indulged their vanity, they will praise you in turn and prefer you above others... Such is the vanity of mankind that minding what others say is a much surer way of pleasing them than talking well ourselves."
Franklin went on to catalog the most common conversational sins "which cause dislike", the greatest being "talking overmuch... which never fails to excite resentment." The only thing amusing about such people, he joked, was watching two of them meet: "The vexation they both feel is visible in their looks and gestures; you shall see them gape and stare and interrupt one another at every run, and watch with utmost impatience for a cough or pause, when they may crowd a word in edgeways."
The other sins on his list were, in order: seeming uninterested, speaking too much about your own life, prying of personal secrets ("an unpardonable rudeness"), telling long and pointless stories ("old folks are most subject to this error, which is one chief reason their company is so often shunned"), contradicting or disputing someone directly, ridiculing or railing against things except in small witty doses ("it's like salt, a little of which in some cases gives relish, but if thrown on by handfuls spoils all"), and spreading scandal (though he would later write lighthearted defenses of gossip).
The older he got, the more Franklin learned (with a few notable lapses) to follow his own advice. He used silence wisely, employed an indirect style of persuasion, and feigned modesty and naïveté in disputes. "When another asserted something that I thought an error, I denied myuself the pleasure of contradicting him." Instead, he would agree in parts and suggest his differences only indirectly. "For these fifty years past no one has ever heard a dogmatical expression escape me," he recalled when writing his autobiography. This velvet-tongued and sweetly passive style of cirumspect argument would make him seem sage to some, insinuating and manipulative to others, but inflammatory to almost nobody. The method would also become, often with a nod to Franklin, a staple in modern management guides and sel-improvement books." (ISAACSON: Benjamin Franklin. An American life.)
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario