Unit 3. Action
Part II: Responsibility & Freedom
To be guilty of an offense/crime
be responsible in a degree for sth that happens
To take/assume the responsibility to/for sth.
To dodge/avoid/duck the responsibility for sth.
To be responsible for/to someone or sth.
ACTIVITY 0: DEGREES IN RESPONSIBILITY
1st.- Read this story and pay attention to what does each of the characters featuring in it: a busy husband, an unfaithful wife, a stingy lover, an aggressive crazy man, an experimental psychologist, a strict ferryman, a judgmental friend.
¨A busy husband, too concerned about work and earning money, did not pay much attention to his wife. She was getting really unsatisfied with their relationship, and met another man who rose to the occasion and was trying to seduce her. One day her husband was far from home on a business trip, as usual. And she finally fell for the seduction and spent the night at her lover's house, on the other side of the city.
At daybreak, she hurried up to get back home before her husband arrived. But she stopped before the bridge over the river that she had to cross to get to the other part of the town. On the bridge, she saw a man who looked really aggressive, making strange and violent movements with his arms. A psychiatrist had set this crazy man free in order to experiment on him a new kind of pills.
The woman ran away to an outbound dock by the bridge where a ferryman asked her the money for the ticket, in case she wanted to cross the river by the ferry. As she had left home without any money, she begged him to let her onto the boat for free, and promised him to pay him later. But the ferryman refused to let her on without paying first. Therefore, she ran back to her lover´s house, so as to borrow money from him, but he refused to lend her any money at all. Then, she remembered that an old friend of hers also lived in that part of town too. When he was young, he admired her and was in love with her, but she had wanted them only to be friends. But when she explained to him what she needed money for, he felt completely disappointed at her behavior, got really angry and also refused to give her anything but his criticism.
Finally, she made up her mind, and decided to cross the bridge. But the madman attacked her and murdered her.¨
2nd.- In five minutes, think about which one is for you the most responsible character and the least responsible one for what happens in the story, explaining the reasons why you think it is so. (If you end before your classmates, you can think about the reasons for the position of the rest of the characters in-between them).
3rd.- In another five minutes, you can move around the class without being loud, and discuss the matter with other classmates, giving them your reasons, trying to convince them, but listening to theirs also, and maybe they convince you to improve yours.
4th.- This is an active listening exercise in class: Finally, all the class will listen and try to understand the reasons why each student will consider the most or the least responsible one character or another. And the teacher will draw the general criteria of responsibility making variations into the story.
1.- Two reasons why a person is responsible in some degree for something that happens:
a) knowledge: TO BE ABLE TO KNOW WHAT HAPPENS AND ITS CONSEQUENCES.
b) willpower: TO BE ABLE TO DECIDE/CHOOSE AMONG DIFFERENT WAYS OF BEHAVIOR.
ACTIVITY 1.- APPLY THE TWO CRITERIA SHOWING RESPONSIBILITY IN EACH CHARACTER.
a) could the character know what was happening and its consequences?
what could he know? and how could he know that?
b) could the character have decided to choose another way of action?
what other actions could he do?
busy husband: -he couldn't have known that his wife was in danger,
because he was on a business trip.
-he couldn't have decided/chosen to do anything about that,
because he knew nothing about that.
unfaithful wife:
-she could have known that crossing was dangerous,
because she saw an aggressive man on the bridge.
-she could have decided to act otherwise:
not to cross the bridge, to call the police, to stay by her lover or by her old friend,...
stingy lover:
-he could have known that the woman was in danger,
because he could have asked her, and she could have told him.
-he could have decided to act in another way:
to call the police, to ask her to stay and wait, to accompany her, to escort her to the bridge, to take her home, to call a taxi for her,...
crazy man:
-he can't know what he is doing,
because he isn't aware of the meaning and implications of his actions.
-he isn't able to act in another way (to choose anything he does),
because he isn't able to control his impulses (his will is alienated)
experimental psychiatrist:
-he could know that releasing a madman into town was dangerous, because a crazy man could hurt any other citizen.
-he could have decided to act in another way:
not to have set the madman free, not to have experimented on him,
to have escorted the madman and never left him alone,...
strict ferryman:
-he could have known that the woman was in danger,
because he could have asked her, and she could have told him.
-he could have decided to act in another way:
to call the police, to advise her not to cross the bridge and wait,...
judgmental old friend:
-he could have known that the woman was in danger,
because she had told him about that.
-he could have decided to act in another way:
to warn the police, to ask her to stay and wait, to accompany her to the bridge, to take her home, to call a taxi for her,...
2.- Definition: TO BE GUILTY OF an offense or a crime: when somebody does something...
a) that denies a civil right of a particular individual.
b) the consequences of which, can put in danger an aspect of the general welfare for anybody
ACTIVITY 2.- WHICH OFFENSES COMMITED THE PSYQUIATRIST?
a) has he denied any civil right of a particular individual?
b) did the consequences of his action put in danger an aspect of the general welfare for any citizen?
-The psychiatrist has denied the physical and moral integrity of the crazy man,
because he decided to do an experiment on a human being without permission.
-The psychiatrist has put in danger the public safety,
because he decided to set a madman free who could do any harm to anybody.
3.- EMPATHY. we expect that humans feel empathy even for strangers when someone is in trouble or suffering.
The feeling of ...(a) being HAPPY (in some degree) when something GOOD happens to a person (a stranger) that didn't do anything BAD;
...(b) being SAD (in some degree) when something BAD happens to a person (a stranger) that didn't do anything WRONG to deserve it.
This feeling moves people to do humanitarian or solidarity actions.
ACTIVITY 3.- THINK OF WHEN WE COULD HAVE EVER FELT EMPATHY...
(A) FOR OTHER PEOPLE'S SUFFERING,
-...
-...
-...
-...
(B) FOR OTHER'S PEOPLE JOY.
-...
-...
-...
-...
4. Three meanings in 'responsibility'
1st.- To be responsible in some degree for something that happened, when we could (a) know what happened and its consequences, and (b) decide to act otherwise
ACTIVITY 4.1.- Explain the different degrees in responsibility of each character, ¿is also any of them at fault for something?:
“Some naughty classmates have done a big mischief and fear to be punished by the headmaster of the school. Some others lie for them to conceal/cloak that action and cover them up. And the rest of the class keep quiet, because they want to dodge any trouble with them.”
2nd.- (- ) To dodge/avoid/duck our degree in responsibility for something that happened: to deny that we could (a) know what happened and (b) act otherwise.
(+) To take/assume our degree in responsibility for something that happened: to accept/admit that we could (a) know it and (b) act otherwise.
ACTIVITY 4.2.- Explain in each case how they dodge their responsibility, and what do they put the blame on.
a) An old friend of ours does something that hurts us and says this to us: 'I didn't know that it would make you feel so bad, otherwise I wouldn't have done it'
b) A girl/boyfriend is extremely jealous and don't want his/her boy/girlfriend to go out with his/her friends, and says: 'you're at fault for that, because you don't love me enough:I am like that and I cannot change'
c) A son/daughter refuses to study anything nor comply with what his/her parents advise him/her to do, and says: 'You both don't understand how much effort it takes, as my friends' parents do'.
d) A classmate gets angry and starts to insult other classmates, and, afterwards, says: 'you must understand me, it's just that a had a bad day'
e) A man gets into a quarrel and beats someone up, and he (and his relatives) say: 'It's just that I/he was completely drunk'.
3rd.- (+) To be responsible for/to something/somebody: to have willingly committed to take care for somebody or to perform some task, and do it.
(- ) To be an irresponsible person: to have willingly committed to take care for somebody or to perform some task, and not to have complied with it.
ACTIVITY 4.3.- Try to explain these examples of being responsible and irresponsible.
a)-a responsible father/mother vs. an irresponsible father/mother
b)-a responsible son/daughter vs. an irresponsible son/daughter
c)-a responsible student vs. an irresponsible student.
Vocabulary and expressions:
place the blame for sth on sb (achacar la culpa de algo a alguien)
to shift our responsibility to sth (pasar nuestra respnsabilidad a alguien)
to pass the buck to one another (pasarse la pelota de uno a otro)
responsibility
accountability (rendición de cuentas a alguien por algo)
liability *obligación, responsabilidad civil
guiltiness/culpability (culpabilidad)
to be guilty of doing something (ser culpable de hacer algo)
to blame something on somebody (echar la culpa de algo a alguien)
shame (verguenza) to be/feel ashamed (sentirse avergonzado)
to shame sb, to embarras sb (avergonzar a alguien)
I am at fault for doing something (tengo la culpa/soy culpable de hacer eso)
I am to blame for this (soy a quien hay que echar la culpa por eso)
I will assume the blame for this (asumiré la culpa de eso)
I'll take the fall/hit (yo asumiré la culpa)
offense - criminal offense – crime
huge offense – petty crime (petty theft) (delito grave – delito menor (pequeño robo-hurto)
felony (delito grave/crimen) -misdemeanor (delito leve)
to be responsible for something
to be accountable for something to somebody obligado a rendir cuentas por algo ante alguien (que exige responsabilidades. respuestas, informe)
to commit an offence/a crime
to commit oneself to make/do something (comprometerse a hacer algo)
to be convicted of a crime/a criminal offense
impeachment, indictment (inculpamiento)
an accomplice (un cómplice)
an enabler (alguien que hace posible una acción/un delito)
to complain to (querella ante)
to charge, to accuse, (acusar, dictar cargos)
to neglect something (ser negligente en algo)
busy (ocupado), business (negocio), businessman (hombre de negocios)
show business (mundo del espectáculo)
unfaithful (infiel)
to cheat on somebody (engañar a alguien -a la pareja)
stingy (tacaño, avaro)
greedy (ambicioso, codicioso)
crazy, mad (loco)
there are those who commit the crime and there are those who aid and abet (complices o inductores)
to abet (instigar, incitar)
psychologist /psaikoloyist/, psychiatrist /psaikaiatrist/
boatman (barquero), ferryman
the characters (los personajes)
to feature (estar presente) (featuring: presentando)
a feature (un papel, una función, un rol)
outbound dock (muelle de salida), wharf (embarcadero)
to refuse to do something (rechazar, negarse a hacer algo, no aceptar hacer algo)
to deny something (negar algo)
to concern about something (preocuparse por algo)
to pay attention to sth/sb. (prestar atención a algo/alguien)
to meet sb. (conocer a alguien, encontrarse con alguien)
to rise to the occasion (aprovechar la oportunidad)
to fall for the seduction (caer en la seducción)
to spend the night with sb. (pasar la noche con alguien)
to experiment on sb sth (experimentar con alguien algo)
to beg (implorar, rogar)
to borrow (pedir prestado)
to lend (dejar prestado)
to disappoint sb. (decepcionar a alguien)
to deceive sb (engañar a alguien)
to make up one's mind (decidirse -a hacer algo-)
more or less (más o menos)
the most or the least (el que más, el que menos )
Empathy (empatía)
feeling (sentimiento)
stranger (alguien a quien no conocemos, un extraño)
foreigner (extranjero)
to be in trouble (tener problemas)
to be at some risk (estar bajo algún riesgo)
to suffer (sufrir), to enjoy (disfrutar), joy (disfrute, felicidad, alegría, gozo)
to move somebody to do something (motivar a alguien a hacer algo)
to feel sorrow for something that happens to somebody (sentir tristeza por algo que le pasa a alguien)
humanitarian/solidarity actions (acciones humanitarias/solidarias)
public safety (seguridad ciudadana)
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario